- + Poldimpailm joined Debatewise
- + Moogmaclan I joined Debatewise
- + Werbehoguehob joined Debatewise
- + Urbaday joined Debatewise
- + Saachin.Simpson joined Debatewise
- + Mantcece Sed603 joined Debatewise
- + Sararozmus joined Debatewise
- + Varma joined Debatewise
- + Scoolfeds joined Debatewise
- + Seniallealm joined Debatewise
- + Nirmal Kumar joined Debatewise
- + Zaini Zainab joined Debatewise
- + Seiliacek Kese897 joined Global Youth Panel
- + Juljul2221 joined Debatewise
- + Patrick Leitch joined Debatewise
- + Locksgydff joined Debatewise
- + Penf Dumn joined Debatewise
- + Timothy Orzeszek joined Debatewise
- + Deonvoff joined Debatewise
- + Steven Allyn Taylor joined Debatewise
- + Skritch joined Debatewise
- + Simpsongqi joined Debatewise
- + Blogsma joined Debatewise
- + Chaci joined Debatewise
- + Barry Nism joined Global Youth Panel
- + Vladstronsy joined Debatewise
- + Eurorcevete joined Debatewise
- + Barry Skaw joined Debatewise
- + Maciej Pielachowski joined Debatewise
- + Yoskha D. Adrianto joined Debatewise
Should private schools be abolished?
Selected Version - Version 2 (Current Version) : 16 Nov 2008 | 13:23 | admin
All versions
Key
- Text coloured Greenhas been added snce the previous version
- Text marked
red and striked-throughhas been deleted
|
Changes from Version 1 to Version 2
|
|||||||
Yes, because... Private Schools inhibit reform of the public system
It is an inevitable feature of democracies that the rich have particular access to politicians and policy-makers. While the rich don't have a need for public education because they can pursue education for their children from other sources, they have no motivation to lobby politicians on behalf of the education system and a perverse incentive to remove education from political agendas in favour of their preferred issues and legislation.
Only by forcing the rich into the same situation as the poor can we expect to gain meaningful ground in terms of education reform, especially in terms of increased funding relative to national and municipal budgets. We cannot expect education will be a national priority until the entire nation has a vested interest in the good order of the system.
By "forcing the rich into the same situation as the poor" there will only be resentment, and the most well off will send their children abroad to more democratic societies where freedom of choice is allowed. This proposition argument assumes that those who are less well off do not have the motivation to lobby Parliament, which is an insult to those who work hard trying to implement education changes, and send their children to state schools.